Home > Personal injury attorney in Carmel, IN > Stewart & Stewart Attorneys Review

Stewart & Stewart Attorneys

Personal injury attorney in Carmel, IN
Reviews: 70 | Overal Rating: Good
Excellect
59
Good
0
Average
1
Bad
1
Awful
9
Thursday Open 24 hours
Friday Open 24 hours
Saturday Open 24 hours
Sunday Open 24 hours
Monday Open 24 hours
Tuesday Open 24 hours
Wednesday Open 24 hours

Reviews

Review Left On 03/01/2020
Cathy Schmucker

They did nothing , Put the family on a rollercoaster, for 2 years, The Dr got away with slowly killing my mother.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Amber Patton

Stewart and Stewart is by far the BEST Law Firm in the state of Indiana. They do their jobs very well also the paralegal attorneys that work for them are Very knowledgeable and professional.
The second thing that makes them a Great firm is because they're very Passionate, Caring, for their clients.
We feel blessed to have them representing us!!!!!!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Christine Walter (Staff)

I called them initially and got great response. I did not return completed paperwork and was contacted by phone and letter which was really efficient. I then called and left voice voicemail for same employee to call me and three days later my call had not been returned. I called again and a lady there offered to help. When I explained the situation she then decided to try to solve the situation for me. I clearly did not want to discuss my circumstances with her and became irritated and frustrated as her advice was not useful. I went on to ask her who she was and what her position was in the company and she accused me of being rude. I asked several times and she refused to inform me. Whoever she was she certainly had no experience of trying to defuse a volatile situation so I just hung up. This person definitely needs some kind of training dealing with the public when a situation gets out of hand. I was not at all rude to her maybe irritated, frustrated and impatient and with a little attitude when she refused to answer my question. I will not be seeking there assistance in the future.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Nancy Williams

Hard working law team
Review Left On 03/01/2020
gary truitt

I was very happy with the results!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Jane Retz

They were very helpful and knowledgeable about my case. If you are seeking professionalism and excellence I highly recommend this firm. Kameron Petro and Nickolas Wagner were there for any concerns I had. They were a great help.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Jordan Turley

People were very friendly here
Review Left On 03/01/2020
dorel iancu

Great people working there.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
joseph constant

It was a very pleasant experience dealing with Stewart & Stewart, everyone was very pleasant and eager to help and answer all my questions and help get what I deserved. No pressure very professional!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Katie Feldhake

Although I did not formerly present a case to the attorneys at Stewart and Stewart, I spoke with one of their paralegals who directed me through some legal paperwork I had been issued. Their staff is friendly, knowledgeable, attentive, and professional. I would come to this team with any questions in the future.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Carol Miller

Brandon, Michelle, Audrey, and Dora have been wonderful and very patient in helping me with my cases. All have worked with me to assist me, despite a brain injury, to follow and understand my case. Professional without sacrificing compassion.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
D. Doris S.

I am so grateful for the wonderful Stewart & Stewart Medical Malpractice team. I couldn't ask for better representation. Lori was always there for me. She never failed to answer a question. She held my hand throughout the whole process and went above and beyond her duties. Thank you all!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
C Filo

Medical Malpractice team was amazing and very caring. Lori was always there to answer any questions I had. Best people to have on your side!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Kristi Adams

Stewart and Stewart did an amazing job with my case. They were very professional and attentive! I would highly recommend them.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Lane Johnson

I called this firm with questions about property damage. Even though I wasn’t hurt in the wreck they took the time to answer my questions and didn’t rush me off the phone. If I ever have a need in the future, I will absolutely call them!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Ashley Johnson

Great firm!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Lexi Video

You can't find a better firm to help you if you've been in a car accident. Highly recommend!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Julie Tevis

Very professional and understanding of our situation... they worked hard and communicated with us every step of the way!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Susan Harrison

Handled a difficult SSD claim for me. They were up front on the long course of action that would be involved. I got quarterly updates on what they needed from my doctors. If I received information from Social Security and I had questions I would get a call back by the end of the day. I was told what would happen every step of the way. The hardest thing about the legal system is you have to be prepared to wait. If something was happening with my case I heard from them right away. If not you can drive yourself crazy ticking the days off on a calendar. Great job Stewart & Stewart!
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Robin Pemberton

They are very pushy. If you don't do things the way they want then you are very rude. Their attorney call and are rude on the phone. And even hang up on you. I didn't even get you say more than ten words on the phone. Some way to run a business.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
L B

A local attorney referred us to this office for my father's medical malpractice case. They told us they would accept the case, and we signed some paperwork. They were on his case for a year, and I was very unhappy that no one ever reached out to let us know what was going on with the case. I had to dog them for updates on what was going on. It took them 4 months to get his medical records. It took the 7 months to review his records. Every time I spoke with them, they would tell me something like "x person will be finishing y next week" and then it would be another month, and I'd contact them again only to be told the same thing. Finally they tell me they are working on a plan of action with the attorney. The next thing I know, my dad gets a letter from them saying they are no longer pursuing the case. No reason given whatsoever. They held onto this for a year when we could have been working with a better attorney. They didn't contact me letting me know this, even though I had been the one contacting them consistently. So now the statute of limitations has almost run out because Stewart and Stewart hung on to this for so long and did nothing.
Review Left On 03/01/2020
Nathan Scalf

Woman on the phone was rude and talked to me like I was a moron. They wanted to handle the easy workman's comp. Not the personal injury or wrongful termination.
Review Left On 02/25/2020
Anthony Denning

Tiffany Guthrie did an outstanding job in representing me in my case. She went above and beyond as well as making me feel comfortable and at ease with the process. She was patient, listened to my situation and worked hard to get me the best result possible. She communicated with me thoroughly and kept me updated on any changes to my case. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is in need of a attorneys assistance in an employment case. Awesome job !!!
Review Left On 01/01/2020
Finda Loeb

Great service, great Attorneys!!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Mark Peerman

Amazing staff! They exceeded my expectations and I would highly recommend.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Olivia Kilburn

This reputable company provides great service! Stephanie D. is super helpful and friendly!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Jordan Mckinney

Very helpful - Stephanie was very helpful in laying out all our options.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Susan Coyle

Had a great experience with this firm and it's employees. I was unfortunately not able to work with them on my case due to it not being an area they handled, however the nice lady on the phone was able to direct me to the Indiana BAR association who referred me to some folks to help me out! I am very appreciative of this firms patience and help on my stressful journey!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Siah Turay

Great service.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
jamie harvey

Very attentive and compassionate staff! Extremely helpful intake staff that was very professional and courteous! Highly recommend!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Becca Wisner

Good people and nice firm. I highly recommend them.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Matthew Fiore

A very professional law firm with lots of caring and hard working employees. Highly recommend Stewart & Stewart!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Colby Cronnin

Awesome intake team! I recommend you go here if you’re having any legal trouble.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Joseph Wisner

Wonderful firm, great, understanding employees
Review Left On 12/01/2019
David Cronnin

My experience with Stewart and Stewart attorneys in Carmel Indiana was very positive, they knew all the answers and gave me so many different options. I would definitely recommend them. Extremely professional and caring.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Lisa Atarian

They're very responsive and easy to work with.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Andile Songo

Staff was very helpful.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Bill Bostock

I recently became a client of Stewart and Stewart and am thoroughly impressed with there attentiveness and responsiveness. On my first meeting I met with Lisa Everling who introduced me to other team members on day one to address my wrongful termination. Since that time, Lisa and her team have been on top of everything and proactively keeping me informed. As a result, I feel like I am in GREAT hands with Stewart and Stewart!

Bill
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Tyler Clemons

Stewart & Stewart will work with you through any situation. They’re a very positive and polite firm!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Dumile Xaba

“great staff, I would recommend seeking legal aide with these guys!”
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Thembi

Such a great law firm! All of the staff is very helpful and encouraging. They even have a polite intake specialist! Thanks Stewart and Stewart.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Thandeaux

This law firm is top of the line. The staff is professional. I worked with Anesu and she was obviously very educated and experienced. I will definitely be recommending Stewart & Stewart to all of my family members in case they ever need an attorney.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Davis D

Incredible staff that always has a great attitude. Highly recommend!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Emma Stiggleman

Great team with an amazing atmosphere!
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Jada Tompkins

The staff at Stewart and Stewart we’re very friendly considerate and helpful. They made me feel at ease during my interaction working with their office. I never felt left out of the loop. There workers were dedicated to the end. 10/10 would recommend.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
S c

They was ok to me
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Stephen Watts Jr.

Very helpful firm that is always very pleasant and polite. Would highly recommend to anyone with any legal troubles.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Kelly Stiggleman

Great team of paralegals and Attorneys that were super helpful
Review Left On 12/01/2019
cole davis

Very friendly and knowledgeable staff who is willing to work with you, unlike some other law firms in the area.
Review Left On 12/01/2019

I am totally satisfied with my experience with my Attorney Nick Wagner. He explained everything very well to me and was very honest with me about everything . I am so glad that I chose Stewart & Steward to represent me in my case.
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Francis Greycloud

DO NOT HIRE THIS FIRM!!! THEY DROP MY CASE CAUSE THEY CHICKEN OUT ON THE FIRM THEY HAD TO WORK AGAINST. READ THEIR REVIEWS!!!
EVEN THEIR OWN LAYERS TELL YOU NOT TO HIRE THIS FIRM. I went threw 2 lawyers cause they Quit the firm. OMG THEY SUXXXXX
Review Left On 12/01/2019
Ashlee Pickett

They were great! Stephanie always kept me informed and helped me through the whole process.
Review Left On 11/01/2019
Joshua Adams

I had a great experience with attorney Nicholas J. Wagner. I am very happy with the settlement and the process that we went through together. Communication between us was fast and professional with his paralegal. Their service they provided was beyond my expectations. Seriously would recommend going through Stewart & Stewart.
Review Left On 10/01/2019
Max Eckman

my experience with Stewart & Stewart was amazing. my lawsuit was against my own auto insurance company. This company has had a history of low balling their payouts. The legal advice I was given was direct, easy to follow and understand as a laymen, and most importantly, correct.

I hope and wish that I never have to be in this situation again. But. If i am. I am calling Stewart and Stewart. No question about it.
Review Left On 10/01/2019
Jason Hill

Good people. They know the law
Review Left On 10/01/2019
Myra Price

My experience with Stewart and Stewart I will say was long however efficient. I wanna thank the staff paralegals everyone that helped with my case. They most definitely put the clients best interest in hand.
Review Left On 10/01/2019
Kim Reed

Couldn't be happier with how quick and effective my brother's case was handled. The day I called they were there within 3hrs... Everything was explained to us in detail and accuracy....even after the case was settled the company went over and beyond to help satisfy our needs-thank you Michelle Adams for your extra care
Review Left On 09/01/2019
Helen Jones

You all did a great job. They are very considerate, thorough, and get the best settlement possible. Thank you Darron Michelle and Audrey.
Review Left On 09/01/2019
Gerardo Rodriguez

They were very attentive with my Workers' Compensation case
Review Left On 09/01/2019
Ronnie Trostle

From the very first phone call to the initial home visit and all throughout the fact finding calls and sessions, I can't begin to tell you about the in-depth knowledge and genuine care they gave to me. I was even more surprised about the core group of legal Professionals assigned to my case. Just to name a few and special thank yous to Mr. Nicholas "Nick" Wagner such a great stratigic legal mind that covers all his bases with facts. Extra special Thanks to Mrs. Stephanie Matzenbacher always getting me accurate and extremely quick answers to all my questions, and believe me I had alot! Thank you Mr. Darron Stewart and the entire staff it was a long 4 1/2 years and I feel at the end of it all we got a fair settlement GREAT WORK everyone. Last but not least Janet I will miss calling and hearing your upbeat voice! GET WHAT YOU DESERVE GET STEWART AND STEWART. They are AWESOME!!!!!!!!
Review Left On 06/01/2019
Michael Skyles

I had a great experience with S&S. They where very helpful through the entire process. I would highly recommend them!
Review Left On 06/01/2019
Rob N.

Great firm and team. If I ever need assistance again Stewart and Stewart will be the first firm I'd call. Special thanks to Darren Stewart, Stephanie Matzenbatcher and last but not least Nicholas "Nick" Wagner.
Review Left On 05/01/2019
Rob Jackson

They just completed my case for a auto crash from 4 years ago with a very difficult auto ins. Company. Very happy with the results. They also was able to keep their internal charges low. Good work.
Review Left On 04/01/2019
Ashley Bills

Excellent lawfirm they are proffesional and they are the best lawfirm they are straight forward and nick is the best and their staff thank you Stewart and Stewart you guys are Great!!!
Review Left On 04/01/2019
S B

Extremely satisfied! Thank you Stewart and Stewart!
Review Left On 04/01/2019
Karissa Grove

Our experience with Stewart & Stewart attorneys exceeded all of our expectations. A huge thank you for all your efforts in pursuing and settling the case on behalf of my niece and her infant son. Our thanks go out to everyone on your team who put in their heart and soul into this case.
From the initial meeting we were met with professionalism and the sensitivity needed to handle an infant death case. We were informed from the start what the process was and how long it could take and felt confident that Baby Sterling's case was in the best of hands possible.
My niece was always called when there was a new development and was told to call if she ever wanted to check in when things were quiet. The entire staff of this firm treated her like a person and not just another case. I can’t say enough good things about them.
I don’t know if true justice is ever served, but some aspect of it was served here and that is because of your hard work. Thank you, again for your persistence and friendship through this hard process.
Review Left On 03/01/2018
Renea Saltsgaver

Company took my case then wouldn't call me back. After 3 months and many messages they finally told me they decided not to take my case. Now having a hard time getting all my records back that I gave them.
Review Left On 03/01/2018
Kristie Holder

They did a great job working on my case. I would highly recommend them to anyone.
Review Left On 03/01/2018
Jocelynn Nicholson

they're nice but.........
Review Left On 03/01/2018
Ashleigh Young

I should have listened to the bad reviews on Facebook and Google. Run and run fast. Money hungry and could care less about your case. Unwilling to work with our creditors. We got debt collection calls daily which told us they were not working with them. Wanted to charge another $1800 on top of their $35k fee for "expenses". Asked for an itemized bill and never got it. We had no communication whatsoever from April - September. Complained to the State Board and our complaint was closed. We left multiple voicemails and sent emails. Nothing from them until we fired them. Showed up at the office to get our file and they got defensive and hostile. Our new lawyer will handle everything from here on out. Thank goodness - S&S was stressing us out! I wish I could leave zero stars.

Leave A Review For For Stewart & Stewart Attorneys


Useful Links